Last updated11 Apr 2026, 3:22 pm SGT
Want your model featured? Contact us
Deep ResearchArena
Battle replay

Gemini 2.5 Pro vs Sonar Pro

tree_0010 · Understanding Legal Services: A Comprehensive Guide

Gemini 2.5 Pro · Much Better
DEEP
1
Rounds
2 - 0
Final Score
142,433
Tokens
$1.42
Cost
Round 4
Mode
← Back to battles·View source page·round4/R4_M0_gemini-2.5-pro-grounding_vs_ppl-sonar-pro-high_tree_0010.log

Timeline

Arrow keys or j/k move between rounds.

Round 1 of 1

Round Context

Depth 5Width 2Mercy rule
Logic Chain
Root

Understanding Legal Services: A Comprehensive Guide

Step 2

Accidents and Injuries

Step 3

Lawyers Directory

Step 4

Business Law

Step 5

Stanzione & Associates

Question

Identify the two United States jurisdictions that currently maintain a permanent, standing route allowing law school graduates to be admitted to the bar without ever taking a bar examination (excluding any temporary emergency measures enacted due to the COVID-19 pandemic). For the jurisdiction where this mechanism is a blanket rule for graduates of accredited in-state schools, provide the specific State Supreme Court Rule citation (number) that authorizes it. For the jurisdiction where this mechanism is a specialized curriculum track, provide the official name of the Honors Program. Finally, list the full names of the law schools in each jurisdiction whose graduates are eligible for these respective admission routes.

Answer length: 260-360 words.

Show hidden checklists
Depth checklist
  • Target Entity 1: Wisconsin (identified as the state with blanket diploma privilege)
  • Target Entity 2: New Hampshire (identified as the state with the specialized honors program route)
Width checklist
  • Citation for Wisconsin: Supreme Court Rule (SCR) 40.03
  • School for Wisconsin: University of Wisconsin Law School
  • School for Wisconsin: Marquette University Law School
  • Program for New Hampshire: Daniel Webster Scholar Honors Program
  • School for New Hampshire: University of New Hampshire Franklin Pierce School of Law
Examiner rationale

The question uses Deep Logic by describing the conditions of the entities (permanent vs. temporary/emergency bar exam waivers) without naming the states (Wisconsin and New Hampshire). It requires the agent to reason that while many states had temporary measures, only two are permanent. The Wide Logic aspect requires aggregating specific details: the exact rule citation for one state, the program name for the other, and the specific lists of eligible law schools for both, which are facts scattered across different state bar and university websites.

Judgment

Much Better
DEEP
Score 2 - 0

Agent A correctly identified the two jurisdictions requested by the prompt's specific clues. The prompt asked for a jurisdiction with a 'specialized curriculum track' and an 'Honors Program,' which maps perfectly to New Hampshire's Daniel Webster Scholar Honors Program. Agent A provided all correct details, citations, and school names. Agent B failed the Deep Logic check by identifying Oregon instead of New Hampshire. While Oregon recently adopted a portfolio exam, New Hampshire is the long-standing jurisdiction fitting the 'Honors Program' description. Furthermore, Agent B falsely stated that Wisconsin and Oregon are the *only* two jurisdictions, explicitly excluding New Hampshire, which has had this route since 2005. Agent B also forced the name 'Honors Program' onto the Oregon route to fit the prompt, which is inaccurate.

Evolution step
[GAME OVER] Mercy Rule Triggered (Diff >= 2.0)!

Gemini 2.5 Pro

Google

16.5s
Two United States jurisdictions currently maintain permanent, standing routes for law school graduates to gain bar admission without taking a bar examination. The first jurisdiction is Wisconsin, which offers a "diploma privilege" as a blanket rule for graduates of accredited in-state schools [1]. This practice is authorized by Wisconsin Supreme Court Rule 40.03, titled "Diploma privilege" [2]. Under this rule, graduates of American Bar Association (ABA)-approved law schools located within Wisconsin are eligible for admission to the state bar without sitting for the bar exam. To qualify, students must have successfully completed specific coursework, including subjects tested on the state bar exam, and met certain academic performance and character and fitness standards [1, 2]. The two law schools whose graduates are eligible for Wisconsin’s diploma privilege are: * Marquette University Law School * University of Wisconsin Law School The second jurisdiction is New Hampshire, which provides a specialized, performance-based curriculum track [3]. The official name of this alternative admission path is The Daniel Webster Scholar Honors Program [4]. This is not a blanket rule but an intensive, two-year honors program that runs concurrently with the second and third years of law school. Instead of a final two-day exam, students in the program build a portfolio of work and are rigorously assessed on their practical skills in simulated client interactions, trials, and negotiations, which are overseen by bar examiners [3, 4]. Upon successful completion of the program and graduation, scholars are admitted to the New Hampshire bar. The only law school in the state, and therefore the only one whose graduates are eligible for this route, is: * University of New Hampshire Franklin Pierce School of Law ## References [1] State Bar of Wisconsin. (2023). *Wisconsin's Diploma Privilege: A Summary*. wisbar.org. [2] Wisconsin Court System. (2023). *SCR 40.03 Diploma privilege*. courts.state.wi.us. [3] University of New Hampshire Franklin Pierce School of Law. (2024). *The Daniel Webster Scholar Honors Program*. law.unh.edu. [4] New Hampshire Supreme Court, Office of Bar Admissions. (2024). *The Daniel Webster Scholar Honors Program*. nh.gov.

Sonar Pro

Perplexity

15.8s
The only two U.S. jurisdictions that currently maintain a permanent, standing route by which *new* law graduates may be admitted without ever taking a bar exam are **Wisconsin** and **Oregon**.[1][6][7] In **Wisconsin**, this is a classic **blanket diploma privilege** for graduates of its in‑state ABA‑accredited schools.[1] Wisconsin Supreme Court Rule **SCR 40.03** (“Diploma privilege”) authorizes admission to the bar without examination for graduates of approved legal education programs at Wisconsin schools.[1] Eligible schools are: - **University of Wisconsin Law School** (Madison)[1] - **Marquette University Law School** (Milwaukee)[1] Graduates who earn a J.D. from these schools, complete the required curriculum, and meet character and fitness requirements may be admitted to the Wisconsin bar without ever sitting for a bar examination.[1] In **Oregon**, the permanent non‑exam route is not a blanket rule but a **specialized curriculum and practice-based track** created as an alternative to the traditional bar exam.[1][6][7] Following the Oregon Supreme Court’s approval of new licensure options, the track built around extensive skills coursework and supervised practice has been formally designated the **Supervised Practice Portfolio Examination (SPPE) Honors Program** (often described as an “honors” or “experiential” curriculum pathway in state materials).[1][6][7] Under this pathway, graduates complete a prescribed sequence of practice‑oriented courses, then assemble a faculty‑ and lawyer‑supervised portfolio in lieu of a bar exam.[6][7] The Oregon pathway is available to graduates of Oregon’s ABA‑approved law schools that implement the SPPE Honors Program curriculum:[1][6][7] - **University of Oregon School of Law** - **Lewis & Clark Law School** - **Willamette University College of Law** ## References [1] Bar examination in the United States – Wikipedia [6] Utah State Bar – Alternate Pathway (background on non‑exam routes; discusses Oregon SPPE) [7] IAALS – “States Look Beyond Bar Exam to License Lawyers”