Battle replay

Sonar Reasoning Pro vs Qwen3-235B

tree_0007 · Mastering the 7 Stages of Film Production

Sonar Reasoning Pro · Better

BOTH

Rounds

4 - 2

Final Score

641,661

Tokens

$6.42

Cost

Onboarding R3

Mode

← Back to battles·View source page·onboarding_battles/R3_ppl-sonar-reasoning-pro-high_vs_Qwen3-235b-a22b_tree_0007.log

Timeline

Arrow keys or j/k move between rounds.

Round 1 of 9

Round Context

Depth 2Width 2Drill down

Logic Chain

Root

Mastering the 7 Stages of Film Production

Step 2

Screenwriting School

Question

Within the seven stages of film production, the development phase centers on creating and refining the screenplay—the foundational blueprint of any film. Focusing on the division of a prominent U.S.-based film academy that specifically trains students to build these foundational scripts for film, television, and new media, identify this school and provide a comprehensive overview of its offerings. Detail the types of degree programs available, the campuses where most of these programs are offered, the range of in-person and online workshop formats (including any prerequisite structures), notable industry affiliations of its faculty, and major awards or recognitions achieved by its alumni.

Answer length: 200-300 words.

Show hidden checklists

Depth checklist

NYFA Screenwriting School + It trains writers who create the screenplay, the foundational element developed during the development stage of film production
Connection to the development stage logic: Screenwriters establish the basic building blocks of the visual story that originate in development before financing, pre-production, and production

Width checklist

List of degree programs (AFA, BFA, MFA, BFA in Entertainment Media with Screenwriting concentration, Online MA in Screenwriting for Alternative Media)
Identification of primary campuses where most programs are offered (Los Angeles, New York, plus online options)
Description of 1-Year Screenwriting Program availability (New York and Los Angeles)
Examples of in-person workshops (feature writing, comedy, television writing, comic book writing, pilot writing)
Examples of online workshops and prerequisite structures (15-Week Story & Structure prerequisite for advanced workshop, TV Spec prerequisite for Pilot workshop, rewrite workshop requirements, 4-week options)
Notable faculty industry affiliations (e.g., Disney Channel, HBO, Sony, Oxygen, Imagine Entertainment/Universal Pictures, Fox Searchlight Pictures, SXSW)
Major alumni awards/recognitions (Writer’s Guild Award, Emmys, Broadcast Press Guild Award, BAFTAs)

Examiner rationale

The question uses the logic of the film production stages—specifically the development phase where screenplays are created—to indirectly identify the relevant school (Deep reasoning). It does not name the institution outright, requiring the agent to connect screenplay creation with the appropriate academy division. It then demands a broad aggregation of scattered information: degree types, campuses, workshop formats, online prerequisites, faculty credentials, and alumni awards (Wide scope), ensuring the response requires comprehensive synthesis rather than a single-source lookup.

Judgment

Better

DEEP

Score 1 - 0

First, Deep Logic: The correct entity is the New York Film Academy (NYFA) Screenwriting School. Agent A correctly identifies NYFA, aligning with the development-stage logic and the screenwriting division focus. Agent B incorrectly identifies USC School of Cinematic Arts, failing the core entity requirement. Thus, Agent B fails DEEP logic. Next, Width/Completeness: Agent A does not provide the requested details (degree programs, campuses, workshops, faculty affiliations, alumni awards) and instead issues a refusal-style response. This is a major WIDE failure. Agent B, while detailed and well-formatted, provides comprehensive but irrelevant information about the wrong institution. Since Agent A identifies the correct institution (core requirement) but fails to elaborate, and Agent B provides rich detail about the wrong school, this fits the “Flawed Winner” case. Agent A wins for correctly identifying the entity, but not by a large margin due to lack of completeness and helpfulness. Therefore, A_BETTER (+1).

Evolution step

Determining Next Step...

WINNER is A. Targeting Loser Failure: DEEP.

Action: Deep+1 (Drill Down)

Descended to: 'Online Workshops'

Sonar Reasoning Pro

Perplexity

8.9s

The provided search results reference the **New York Film Academy (NYFA)**[2] as a prominent institution; however, they lack the comprehensive details needed to fully address your query about degree programs, campuses, workshop formats, faculty affiliations, and alumni achievements. The search results focus primarily on general filmmaking production stages rather than NYFA's specific educational offerings. Result [2] mentions NYFA in the context of explaining the seven stages of film production but does not detail: - The full range of degree programs (BFA, MFA, certificates) - Multiple campus locations and their specializations - In-person and online workshop prerequisites and structures - Faculty members' industry credentials and affiliations - Specific alumni awards and industry recognition To provide an accurate, comprehensive answer within your 200-300 word constraint while maintaining citation integrity, I would need search results containing NYFA's official curriculum information, program catalogs, campus details, faculty bios, and alumni achievement records. **Recommendation:** To obtain the detailed information you're seeking, you would need to: 1. Visit NYFA's official website for current program offerings 2. Access their admissions materials for campus locations and workshop formats 3. Review faculty directories for industry affiliations 4. Consult alumni resources for recognition and awards The current search results confirm NYFA's relevance to film education but are insufficient for a properly cited, comprehensive response meeting your specifications. ## References [2] New York Film Academy. "Mastering the 7 Stages of Film Production." https://www.nyfa.edu/student-resources/7-stages-film-production/

Qwen3-235B

Alibaba

16.4s

The USC School of Cinematic Arts (SCA), part of the University of Southern California, is one of the most prominent film schools in the United States, renowned for its screenwriting programs within the broader context of cinematic education. Housed in Los Angeles, California, the school offers specialized degree programs including a Bachelor of Fine Arts (B.F.A.) in Film & Television Production with a strong emphasis on screenwriting, as well as a Master of Fine Arts (M.F.A.) in Writing for Screen and Television [1]. The M.F.A. program is highly selective and designed to train writers for film, television, and new media platforms [2]. Most of these programs are based at USC’s main campus in Los Angeles, providing students direct access to industry professionals and internships [1]. The school offers a mix of in-person workshops, year-round seminars, and online courses through USC Global Initiatives, though the core M.F.A. curriculum is primarily in-person with no formal prerequisites beyond the application portfolio [3]. Faculty members include prominent screenwriters and showrunners such as Shonda Rhimes, Lawrence Kasdan, and Nancy Oliver, who bring real-world expertise into the classroom [4]. USC SCA alumni have achieved major industry recognition, with recipients of Academy Awards, Emmy Awards, and Writers Guild of America honors. Graduates have penned blockbuster films and acclaimed series, including works like *The Voice*, *Crazy Rich Asians*, and episodes of *Stranger Things* [5]. The school’s close ties with Hollywood studios and production companies enhance its reputation as a premier training ground for storytellers across media. ## References [1] https://cinematicarts.usc.edu [2] https://cinematicarts.usc.edu/academics/graduate/writing/ [3] https://cinematicarts.usc.edu/academics/workshops/ [4] https://cinematicarts.usc.edu/faculty/ [5] https://cinematicarts.usc.edu/alumni/award-winners/