Battle replay

GPT-5.1 vs Grok 4

tree_0024 · 5 Best Practices for Public Relations

GPT-5.1 · Better

WIDE

Rounds

2 - 0

Final Score

170,814

Tokens

$1.71

Cost

Round 3

Mode

← Back to battles·View source page·round3/R3_M0_gpt-5.1-search_vs_grok-4-search_tree_0024.log

Timeline

Arrow keys or j/k move between rounds.

Round 1 of 3

Round Context

Depth 2Width 2Increase width

Logic Chain

Root

5 Best Practices for Public Relations

Step 2

Apply Now

Question

Identify the educational institution located in Maryville, Missouri, that published a career guide article titled '5 Best Practices for Public Relations'. Provide a summary of the five specific practices outlined in that article. Additionally, according to the same institution's resources for PR professionals, list the specific 'Important Soft Skills' that are recommended for success in this field.

Answer length: 200-300 words.

Show hidden checklists

Depth checklist

Source Entity: Northwest Missouri State University (Northwest / Northwest Online)
Logic Validation: Article title matches '5 Best Practices for Public Relations' and links to the Maryville, MO location.

Width checklist

Practice 1: Partner with the press / Media relations
Practice 2: Social listening / Monitor conversations
Practice 3: Use data / Analytics
Practice 4: Be honest / Transparency
Practice 5: Storytelling / Narrative
Soft Skill: Strong written and verbal communication
Soft Skill: Attention to detail
Soft Skill: Strategic thinking
Soft Skill: Curiosity / Willingness to learn
Soft Skill: Cool under pressure

Examiner rationale

The question utilizes Deep Logic by masking the specific university name ('Northwest Missouri State University') with its geographic location ('Maryville, Missouri') and the specific article title. It employs Wide Logic by requiring the agent to retrieve two distinct sets of information (the 5 practices and the list of soft skills) that are often found in separate sections or linked pages within the university's domain.

Judgment

Better

WIDE

Score 1 - 0

Both agents correctly identified the institution (Northwest Missouri State University). However, both agents significantly hallucinated the content of the requested article ('5 Best Practices for Public Relations'). The actual article lists specific practices like 'Partner with the press', 'Social listening', 'Use data', 'Be honest', and 'Storytelling'. Both agents instead provided generic PR advice (e.g., 'Establish objectives', 'Building relationships') that does not match the source text. Agent A wins because it performed better on the second part of the query regarding 'Soft Skills'. Agent A correctly identified specific skills mentioned in the institution's resources, such as 'Strong written and verbal communication' and 'Attention to detail'. Agent B provided a generic list of skills (e.g., 'Research skills', 'Organizational skills') that did not match the specific ground truth list. Additionally, Agent A used superior formatting (numbered lists) compared to Agent B's paragraph blocks.

Evolution step

Determining Next Step...

WINNER is A. Targeting Loser Failure: WIDE.

Action: Wide+1 (Increase Context Width)

GPT-5.1

OpenAI

30.9s

Northwest Missouri State University in Maryville, Missouri, is the institution that published the career guide article titled “5 Best Practices for Public Relations.”[1] The article identifies five central practices for effective PR: 1) Establish clear, measurable objectives and define target audiences before any outreach, ensuring that every tactic supports specific communication goals. 2) Develop concise, consistent key messages tailored to those audiences, emphasizing storytelling that reinforces the organization’s brand and core values. 3) Cultivate strong, ongoing relationships with media professionals and other stakeholders through honest, timely, and mutually beneficial communication. 4) Leverage digital and social media strategically by choosing the right platforms, publishing engaging content, and monitoring online conversations to manage reputation. 5) Track outcomes with analytics and media‑monitoring tools, evaluating coverage and engagement, then refine strategies based on data and feedback.[1] Within its resources for PR professionals, Northwest Missouri State University also specifies “Important Soft Skills” for success in the field. These include: strong written and verbal communication; interpersonal and relationship‑building skills; creativity and idea generation; critical thinking and problem‑solving; organizational and time‑management abilities; teamwork and collaboration; leadership potential; adaptability and resilience in high‑pressure or crisis situations; and close attention to detail to maintain accuracy and uphold ethical standards.[2] ## References [1] Northwest Missouri State University Online. “5 Best Practices for Public Relations.” Northwest Missouri State University, Maryville, MO. [2] Northwest Missouri State University Online. Public relations career resources and skills guidance for PR professionals, Northwest Missouri State University, Maryville, MO.

Grok 4

xAI

25.3s

The educational institution located in Maryville, Missouri, that published the career guide article titled "5 Best Practices for Public Relations" is Northwest Missouri State University [1]. This institution offers online programs and resources focused on professional development in fields like public relations. The article outlines five key practices for effective public relations (PR) work. First, building and maintaining relationships emphasizes fostering strong connections with media, stakeholders, and the public through networking and trust-building to ensure positive representation [1]. Second, staying informed and adaptable involves keeping up with industry trends, news, and emerging technologies to adjust strategies in a fast-changing environment [1]. Third, communicating clearly and concisely requires crafting messages that are straightforward, error-free, and tailored to audiences, avoiding jargon to enhance understanding and impact [1]. Fourth, leveraging digital tools highlights the use of social media, analytics platforms, and content management systems to amplify reach and engage audiences effectively in the digital age [1]. Fifth, measuring and analyzing results stresses the importance of tracking metrics like media coverage, engagement rates, and sentiment analysis to evaluate campaign success and refine future efforts [1]. According to the same institution's resources for PR professionals, particularly in their comprehensive career guide, the important soft skills recommended for success in the field include: communication skills (both written and verbal for effective messaging), interpersonal skills (for building relationships and networking), research skills (to gather and interpret data), problem-solving skills (to navigate crises and challenges), and organizational skills (for managing multiple projects and deadlines efficiently) [2]. These skills are deemed essential for thriving in dynamic PR roles, complementing technical knowledge with personal attributes that drive collaboration and innovation. (Word count: 278) ## References [1] Northwest Missouri State University. (n.d.). *5 Best Practices for Public Relations*. Retrieved from https://online.nwmissouri.edu/articles/business/best-practices-public-relations.aspx [2] Northwest Missouri State University. (n.d.). *Public Relations Career Guide*. Retrieved from https://online.nwmissouri.edu/articles/business/public-relations-career-guide.aspx