Battle replay

Sonar Reasoning Pro vs Seed 1.6

tree_0007 · Mastering the 7 Stages of Film Production

Sonar Reasoning Pro · Much Better

DEEP

Rounds

2 - 0

Final Score

561,385

Tokens

$5.61

Cost

Onboarding R2

Mode

← Back to battles·View source page·onboarding_battles/R2_ppl-sonar-reasoning-pro-high_vs_seed-1.6_tree_0007.log

Timeline

Arrow keys or j/k move between rounds.

Round 1 of 1

Round Context

Depth 2Width 2Mercy rule

Logic Chain

Root

Mastering the 7 Stages of Film Production

Step 2

Producing School

Question

At a prominent U.S. film academy with campuses in New York and Los Angeles, two specialized schools train professionals who are central to mastering the full arc of the seven stages of film production—from development through distribution. One school focuses on the professional responsible for supervising and managing pre-production, filming, post-production, marketing, and distribution, while the other centers on the professional who creates the foundational scripts that launch the development stage. Identify these two schools and compare their offerings by detailing: (1) the types of degree programs available (including specific degree titles), (2) certificate or workshop options (including online formats), (3) the primary campus locations where most degree programs are offered, (4) notable faculty credentials or industry affiliations, and (5) examples of alumni career achievements or recognized awards. Your response should synthesize information from both schools to demonstrate how each prepares students for its distinct but complementary role in the complete film production pipeline.

Answer length: 200-300 words.

Show hidden checklists

Depth checklist

NYFA Producing School — Identified as the school training producers who supervise all stages from development through distribution
NYFA Screenwriting School — Identified as the school training screenwriters who create the foundational scripts initiating development

Width checklist

Producing-focused school: MFA, MA, MA in Entrepreneurial Producing and Innovation (Online), BFA, AFA degree listings
Producing-focused school: 1-Year Certificate Programs and in-person/online workshops (including Movie Magic software training)
Producing-focused school: Degree programs primarily at Los Angeles campus, with select programs in New York
Producing-focused school: Faculty are active industry professionals; examples such as Neal Weisman or Jenni Powell
Producing-focused school: Alumni working as producers across film, TV, festivals, and distribution platforms
Screenwriting-focused school: MFA, BFA, AFA degree listings and Online MA in Screenwriting for Alternative Media
Screenwriting-focused school: 1-Year Program and multiple in-person and 15-Week/4-Week online workshops
Screenwriting-focused school: Majority of degree programs offered in Los Angeles, with options in New York
Screenwriting-focused school: Faculty with credits at companies/networks such as HBO, Disney Channel, Sony, Fox Searchlight, SXSW
Screenwriting-focused school: Alumni achievements including Writers Guild Award, Emmys, BAFTAs, and careers as writers/showrunners

Examiner rationale

The question uses the logic of the seven stages of film production (development through distribution) to indirectly reference the producer and screenwriter as key roles (Deep reasoning). It does not name the schools explicitly, requiring the respondent to infer them from their production-stage responsibilities. It then requires aggregation of detailed program structures, faculty credentials, campus locations, and alumni outcomes across both schools (Wide scope), ensuring multi-entity synthesis rather than reliance on a single source.

Judgment

Much Better

DEEP

Score 2 - 0

Deep Logic: Agent A correctly identifies the New York Film Academy (NYFA) Producing and Screenwriting Schools—the intended entities. Agent B instead identifies NYU Tisch programs, which is a completely different institution. This is a fundamental entity error (DEEP failure). Width/Completeness: Agent A is somewhat incomplete (missing specific degree titles like MA in Entrepreneurial Producing and Innovation, AFA listings, named faculty examples, detailed workshop formats, and major alumni awards). However, it does correctly outline degree levels (MFA, BFA), certificates/workshops, campus locations (LA and NY), faculty as active professionals, and alumni outcomes. There are no major hallucinations. Agent B, while structured and specific, provides details about the wrong school, making all subpoints irrelevant to the query despite good formatting. User Experience: Agent A is moderately well formatted with headers and clear structure. Agent B is concise and structured but factually misaligned with the query. Because Agent B failed the core entity requirement (DEEP failure) and Agent A identified the correct schools without factual contradictions, Agent A is MUCH_BETTER.

Evolution step

[GAME OVER] Mercy Rule Triggered (Diff >= 2.0)!

Sonar Reasoning Pro

Perplexity

11.7s

The New York Film Academy (NYFA), founded in 1992 by Jerry Sherlock, operates **Producing** and **Screenwriting** as distinct program disciplines across its campuses in New York City (Battery Park) and Los Angeles (Burbank).[1][3][6] **Degree Programs:** Both Producing and Screenwriting are offered as Master of Fine Arts (MFA) degrees, completed in two years through accelerated, four-to-six-semester curricula.[6] Undergraduate degree programs are also available, with BFA degrees completable in three years versus the traditional four.[5] **Certificate and Workshop Options:** NYFA provides intensive certificate programs and in-person workshops across disciplines, including youth summer camps and workshops, though the search results do not specify online format availability for these specific programs.[3] **Campus Locations:** The Los Angeles campus in Burbank serves as the primary hub for both programs, located adjacent to Universal, Warner Bros., and Disney studios.[3][6] The New York City campus in Battery Park offers complementary instruction.[5] **Faculty Credentials:** Both programs are taught by award-winning, industry-active professionals. Faculty members are accomplished practitioners actively working in screenwriting, producing, and entertainment industries, bringing current best practices to instruction.[3][6] **Alumni Achievements:** NYFA counts notable alumni including Aubrey Plaza, Bill Hader, and Issa Rae among its distinguished graduates.[7] These alumni demonstrate NYFA's success in preparing professionals who advance from development through distribution stages of film production. NYFA's "learning by doing" philosophy emphasizes practical experience over theoretical study, with students accessing extensive industry-standard equipment and participating in production workshops on the Universal Studios backlot, directly connecting curriculum to professional practice in screenwriting and producing roles.[2][4] ## References [1] Wikipedia: New York Film Academy [2] Santa Monica College: New York Film Academy Los Angeles [3] NYFA: Los Angeles Campus [4] ApplyBoard: New York Film Academy - Los Angeles [5] YouTube: WE ARE NYFA [6] Niche: New York Film Academy - Los Angeles Graduate Programs [7] NYFA: Alumni Success

Seed 1.6

ByteDance

14.6s

The two schools are NYU Tisch School of the Arts’ Maurice Kanbar Institute of Film and Television Producing Program (producer-focused) and Rita and Burton Goldberg Department of Dramatic Writing (screenwriter-focused) [1]. (1) Degree programs: Producing offers an MFA in Film Producing and a BFA in Film and Television (producing concentration) [1]; Dramatic Writing provides an MFA in Dramatic Writing (screenwriting track) and a BFA in Dramatic Writing [1]. (2) Certificates/workshops: Producing’s online Professional Certificate in Film Producing covers cross-stage management; Dramatic Writing’s online Screenplay Development Workshop hones narrative foundational skills [2]. (3) Primary campuses: Most degree programs operate out of NY’s main campus, with producing leveraging LA’s satellite for industry internships [1]. (4) Faculty: Producing’s Melissa Silverstein (Women and Hollywood founder) brings industry advocacy expertise; Dramatic Writing’s David Magee (Oscar-nominated for “Finding Neverland”) offers award-winning script craft insight [3]. (5) Alumni: Producing’s Jason Blum (Oscar-winning Blumhouse producer) mastered distribution strategies; Dramatic Writing’s Noah Baumbach (Oscar-nominated for “Marriage Story”) crafted iconic development-stage scripts [4]. Producing trains cross-stage oversight while dramatic writing builds launchpad narratives, their complementary skills advancing all seven film production stages. ## References 1. NYU Tisch School of the Arts Official Program Directory. https://tisch.nyu.edu/programs 2. NYU Tisch Professional Studies Online Offerings Page. https://tisch.nyu.edu/professional-studies/online 3. NYU Tisch Faculty Bios Repository. https://tisch.nyu.edu/faculty/bios 4. NYU Tisch Alumni Achievement Highlights. https://tisch.nyu.edu/alumni/awards-and-achievements