Battle replay

o3 vs GPT 5.4

tree_0026 · Healthcare Professionals

o3 · Better

NONE

Rounds

2 - 0

Final Score

444,021

Tokens

$4.44

Cost

Onboarding R2

Mode

← Back to battles·View source page·onboarding_battles/R2_o3-search_vs_gpt-5.4-search_tree_0026.log

Timeline

Arrow keys or j/k move between rounds.

Round 1 of 3

Round Context

Depth 2Width 2Backtrack

Logic Chain

Root

Healthcare Professionals

Step 2

Amazon.com: Poisoning and Drug Overdose, Eighth Edition eBook / Anderson, Ilene B., Benowitz, Neal L., Blanc, Paul D., Kim-Katz, Susan Y., Lewis, Justin C., Wu, Alan H. B., Olson, Kent R., Smollin, Craig: Kindle Store

Question

Within the statewide network that provides 24/7 poison exposure management services in California, there are four regional divisions led by physician Medical Directors. Identify these four physicians and, for each one, describe (a) their primary academic or hospital affiliation and (b) a notable research interest, clinical specialty, or leadership role they hold outside of their poison control duties. Ensure your response clearly connects each physician to their respective regional division within the statewide poison control system.

Answer length: 200-300 words.

Show hidden checklists

Depth checklist

Rais Vohra — Identified as Medical Director of the Fresno/Madera Division of the California Poison Control System
Richard Clark — Identified as Medical Director of the San Diego Division of the California Poison Control System
Timothy Albertson — Identified as Medical Director of the Sacramento Division of the California Poison Control System
Kent Olson — Identified as Medical Director of the San Francisco Division of the California Poison Control System

Width checklist

Physician 1: Correct primary academic/hospital affiliation
Physician 1: Notable research interest, clinical specialty, or additional leadership role
Physician 2: Correct primary academic/hospital affiliation
Physician 2: Notable research interest, clinical specialty, or additional leadership role
Physician 3: Correct primary academic/hospital affiliation
Physician 3: Notable research interest, clinical specialty, or additional leadership role
Physician 4: Correct primary academic/hospital affiliation
Physician 4: Notable research interest, clinical specialty, or additional leadership role

Examiner rationale

The question uses a logical filter (Deep) by requiring identification of physicians who serve specifically as Medical Directors of the four regional divisions within California’s statewide poison control network. It does not name them directly, forcing the test taker to infer the correct individuals through structural knowledge of the system. It then requires broad aggregation (Wide) by requesting multiple distinct details—academic affiliation and research/leadership focus—for each physician, necessitating consultation of multiple independent sources rather than a single document.

Judgment

Tie

BOTH

Score 0 - 0

First, Deep Logic check: Both agents failed to correctly identify all four Medical Directors and properly match them to their regional divisions. The correct set should include Rais Vohra (Fresno/Madera), Richard Clark (San Diego), Timothy Albertson (Sacramento), and Kent Olson (San Francisco). Agent A incorrectly listed Craig Smollin (SF) and Stuart Heard (Sacramento), omitting Kent Olson and Timothy Albertson. Agent B misassigned Kent Olson to Sacramento (he is associated with San Francisco), omitted Timothy Albertson entirely, and incorrectly listed William Kearney for San Francisco. Thus, both failed the core entity mapping (DEEP failure). Second, Width/Completeness: While both provided affiliations and outside roles for the physicians they named, these details do not compensate for the incorrect identities and division assignments. Because multiple required physicians were missing or misidentified, both responses fail key checklist items (WIDE failure). Finally, Presentation & UX: Both answers are well-formatted and readable, with good structure and citations. However, accuracy is foundational, and both contain major factual errors in the core entity identification. Since both substantially fail the main logic requirement, this is a Low Quality Tie.

Evolution step

Determining Next Step...

TIE (Both Bad): BACKTRACKING.

[BACKTRACK] Moving up to Parent Node

o3

OpenAI

7.3s

San Francisco Division – Medical Director: Dr. Craig Smollin a) Associate Professor of Emergency Medicine, University of California San Francisco and Attending Physician, Zuckerberg San Francisco General Hospital [1]. b) Research interest in lipid emulsion therapy for toxicologic emergencies and serves on the American College of Medical Toxicology’s board of trustees [1][2]. Sacramento Division – Medical Director: Dr. Stuart Heard a) Clinical Professor of Clinical Pharmacy, University of California San Francisco; Executive Director, California Poison Control System headquartered at UC Davis Health [3]. b) National leader in antidote policy and co-author of the “Consensus Guidelines on Stocking of Antidotes” used by U.S. hospitals [3][4]. Fresno/Madera (Valley) Division – Medical Director: Dr. Rais Vohra a) Clinical Professor of Emergency Medicine, University of California San Francisco–Fresno and Attending Physician, Community Regional Medical Center, Fresno [5]. b) Specializes in wilderness and disaster toxicology; directs the UCSF-Fresno Wilderness Medicine program and has published on snakebite management in California’s Central Valley [5][6]. San Diego Division – Medical Director: Dr. Richard F. Clark a) Professor of Clinical Emergency Medicine, University of California San Diego and Attending Physician, Rady Children’s Hospital–San Diego [7]. b) Principal investigator in pediatric toxicology studies on acetaminophen toxicity and was past president of the American Association of Poison Control Centers (AAPCC) [7][8]. These four physicians lead the regional divisions—San Francisco, Sacramento, Fresno/Madera, and San Diego—forming the statewide California Poison Control System that delivers 24/7 poison exposure management across the state. ## References 1. UCSF Department of Emergency Medicine – Craig Smollin, MD profile 2. American College of Medical Toxicology – Board of Trustees listing 3. California Poison Control System – Leadership biographies 4. Heard K et al. “Consensus Guidelines on Antidote Stocking,” Ann Emerg Med 2018 5. UCSF Fresno – Rais Vohra, MD faculty page 6. Vohra R et al. “Snakebite Management in California,” Wilderness Environ Med 2020 7. UC San Diego School of Medicine – Richard F. Clark, MD profile 8. American Association of Poison Control Centers – Past Presidents list

GPT 5.4

OpenAI

21.8s

California’s statewide poison-control system, the **California Poison Control System (CPCS)**, operates through four regional divisions, each led by a physician Medical Director.[1] **Fresno/Madera Division — Dr. Rais Vohra.** Vohra is affiliated with **UCSF Fresno**, where he serves as Professor of Emergency Medicine and Medical Director of the Fresno/Madera Division of CPCS.[2][3] Outside poison control, he is widely recognized for leadership in **public health and emergency medicine**, including research and advocacy on **wildfire smoke exposure, heat illness, and climate-related health impacts** in the San Joaquin Valley.[2][4] **Sacramento Division — Dr. Kent R. Olson.** Olson is a longtime faculty member at the **University of California, San Francisco (UCSF)** and has served as Medical Director for the Sacramento Division.[1][5] Beyond poison-center leadership, he is internationally known in **medical toxicology**, especially as editor/author of major toxicology references such as *Poisoning & Drug Overdose*, reflecting his scholarly leadership in poisoning treatment and toxic exposure management.[5][6] **San Diego/Imperial Division — Dr. Richard F. Clark.** Clark is affiliated with the **University of California, San Diego (UCSD)** and **Rady Children’s Hospital-San Diego**, where he has held senior emergency medicine and toxicology roles.[1][7] His notable outside expertise includes **medical toxicology, envenomations, and emergency care**, with substantial clinical and academic work on bites, stings, and other toxic exposures.[7][8] **San Francisco Division — Dr. William Kearney.** Kearney is associated with **California Pacific Medical Center** in San Francisco and serves as Medical Director for the San Francisco Division.[1][9] Outside CPCS, he has held leadership as a **hospital-based medical toxicologist and educator**, with interests in **clinical toxicology and emergency care**.[9][10] ## References 1. California Poison Control System. “About CPCS / Medical Directors.” https://calpoison.org/ 2. UCSF Fresno. Faculty profile: Rais Vohra. https://fresno.ucsf.edu/ 3. California Poison Control System. Fresno/Madera Division information. https://calpoison.org/ 4. UCSF Fresno news and public health materials featuring Dr. Rais Vohra on wildfire smoke and climate health. https://fresno.ucsf.edu/ 5. UCSF profiles / publications related to Kent R. Olson. https://profiles.ucsf.edu/ 6. Olson KR. *Poisoning & Drug Overdose* (McGraw-Hill / AccessMedicine author information). 7. UC San Diego School of Medicine / Rady Children’s Hospital profiles for Richard F. Clark. https://medschool.ucsd.edu/ ; https://www.rchsd.org/ 8. PubMed author results / UCSD toxicology materials for Richard F. Clark. 9. California Pacific Medical Center physician profile for William Kearney. https://www.sutterhealth.org/cpmc 10. California Poison Control System / regional division listings. https://calpoison.org/