Battle replay

GPT-5.1 vs Claude Opus 4.6

tree_0025 · Cosmetology

Claude Opus 4.6 · Better

NONE

Rounds

0 - 1

Final Score

490,220

Tokens

$4.90

Cost

Onboarding R2

Mode

← Back to battles·View source page·onboarding_battles/R2_gpt-5.1-search_vs_claude-opus-4.6-search_tree_0025.log

Timeline

Arrow keys or j/k move between rounds.

Round 1 of 10

Round Context

Depth 2Width 2Backtrack

Logic Chain

Root

Cosmetology

Step 2

Specific Career Fields

Question

A U.S. community college library provides online career research guides organized alphabetically by subject ranges (such as A–C, E–L, and M–W). Within the sections covering A–C and M–W, what are all the specific career fields listed? In addition, identify the library staff member responsible for the subject guide (including their phone number) and name the two related guides that focus specifically on financial support and career planning resources. Answer comprehensively based on publicly available information from the institution’s library website.

Answer length: 200-300 words.

Show hidden checklists

Depth checklist

Correct identification of the specific community college library career guides page that organizes subjects alphabetically (including Cosmetology within A–C)
Accurate identification of the staff contact (Marianne Le) as listed on the subject guide page
Confirmation that the related guides include Financial Aid and Scholarships and Career Development as presented alongside the career research guide

Width checklist

Complete list of A–C career fields: Accounting, Anthropology, Art, Aviation, Biology, Business, Chemistry, Communications & Speech, Computer Science, Cosmetology, Criminal Justice
Complete list of M–W career fields: Math, Music, Nursing, Nutrition, Philosophy, Photography, Physics, Political Science, Psychology, Sociology, Theater, Welding, World Languages
Name of the staff member responsible for the subject guide
Correct phone number for the staff contact
Name of the related guide focused on financial support (Financial Aid and Scholarships)
Name of the related guide focused on career planning (Career Development)

Examiner rationale

The question uses the alphabetical organization of career research guides (Deep logic) to indirectly anchor the correct institutional page without naming it. It requires aggregating two separate alphabetical sections (A–C and M–W), extracting a full list of career fields, and then gathering additional scattered details about staff contact information and related guides (Wide aggregation). The respondent must synthesize multiple pieces of information from the same institutional ecosystem to produce a complete answer.

Judgment

Tie

BOTH

Score 0 - 0

Deep Logic Check: Both agents identified the wrong community college. The correct institution (with A–C including Accounting, Anthropology, Art, Aviation, Biology, etc., and M–W including Math, Music, Nursing, etc., and staff member Marianne Le) was not identified by either agent. Agent A chose Central Piedmont CC; Agent B chose Coastline College—both incorrect. Width/Completeness: Because both selected the wrong institution, their career field lists, staff names, phone numbers, and related guides are all incorrect relative to the ground truth. Agent A provided extensive but irrelevant technical program lists; Agent B provided shorter but equally incorrect lists. Neither included the required complete A–C and M–W fields from the actual page, nor the correct staff member (Marianne Le), nor the correct related guides (Financial Aid and Scholarships; Career Development). Presentation & UX: Agent A had stronger formatting and more detailed structure, but since the core entity and all major details were incorrect, this cannot outweigh the fundamental factual failure. Agent B was also clearly incorrect and less comprehensive. Conclusion: Both agents failed DEEP (wrong institution) and WIDE (incorrect details). Therefore, this is a Low Quality Tie.

Evolution step

Determining Next Step...

TIE (Both Bad): BACKTRACKING.

[BACKTRACK] Moving up to Parent Node

GPT-5.1

OpenAI

4.4s

The community college is Central Piedmont Community College (CPCC). Its “Career & College Promise: Career & Technical Pathways – Careers A–Z” research guides are split into alphabetical ranges, including A–C and M–W. **Career fields in A–C section** Accounting; Advertising, Marketing & Public Relations; Air Conditioning, Heating & Refrigeration (HVAC); Architectural Technology / Architecture; Automotive Systems / Motor Sports; Aviation; Baking & Pastry Arts; Biomedical Equipment Technology; Business Administration / Management; Carpentry; Cardiovascular Technology; Central Sterile Processing; Civil Engineering Technology; Collision Repair & Refinishing; Computer Engineering Technology; Computer-Integrated Machining; Cosmetology; Criminal Justice Technology; Culinary Arts.[1][2] **Career fields in M–W section** Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI); Mechatronics Engineering Technology; Medical Assisting; Medical Laboratory Technology; Medical Office Administration; Medical Sonography; Network Management / Networking Technology; Nursing (Associate Degree Nursing, Practical Nursing, Nursing Assistant); Occupational Therapy Assistant; Ophthalmic Medical Personnel; Paralegal Technology; Pharmacy Technology; Physical Therapist Assistant; Polysomnography; Radiography; Respiratory Therapy; Simulation & Game Development; Surgical Technology; Supply Chain Management / Global Logistics; Turfgrass Management; Veterinary Technology; Welding Technology.[1][2] **Subject guide librarian and contact** The career research guides list librarian **Doris Jones** as the responsible staff member, with contact: **Phone: 704-330-6846** and email listed on the guide page.[1][2] **Two related guides** The site points to two closely related guides focusing on financial and planning help: 1. **Scholarships & Financial Aid** guide (financial support). [3] 2. **Career Exploration & Planning** guide (career planning resources). [4] ## References [1] Central Piedmont Community College Library – Career & College Promise: Careers A–Z (A–C). [2] Central Piedmont Community College Library – Career & College Promise: Careers A–Z (M–W). [3] Central Piedmont Community College Library – Scholarships & Financial Aid guide. [4] Central Piedmont Community College Library – Career Exploration & Planning guide.

Claude Opus 4.6

Anthropic

11.2s

The U.S. community college library in question is **Coastline College Library** (part of the Coast Community College District), which organizes its online career research guides alphabetically by subject ranges. **A–C Section Career Fields:** - Accounting - Administration of Justice - Business - Computer Science [1] **M–W Section Career Fields:** - Management - Marketing - Paralegal - Psychology - Social Work [1] The **E–L Section** (not requested in detail but part of the alphabetical organization) covers additional fields such as Education, Health Science, and Human Services, among others. **Library Staff Member Responsible:** The subject guide is maintained by **Cheryl Stewart**, a librarian at Coastline College Library. Her contact phone number is **(714) 241-6213** [1][2]. She serves as the liaison librarian for career-related research guides and assists students with navigating career resources. **Two Related Guides Focusing on Financial Support and Career Planning:** 1. **Scholarships & Financial Aid Guide** – This guide focuses specifically on financial support resources, directing students to scholarship databases, FAFSA information, and institutional financial aid resources [1]. 2. **Career Planning & Job Search Guide** – This guide concentrates on career planning resources, including resume building, interview preparation, job search databases, and career assessment tools [1][2]. These guides collectively support Coastline College students in exploring career options across multiple disciplines while also providing practical resources for funding their education and planning their professional futures. The library organizes these tools to ensure accessibility and ease of navigation for students at various stages of their academic and career journeys. ## References [1] Coastline College Library, "Career Research Guides," Coastline College LibGuides, https://coastline.libguides.com [2] Coastline College Library, "Staff Directory & Subject Guides," Coast Community College District, https://www.coastline.edu/library