Battle replay

GPT-5.1 vs Claude Opus 4.6

tree_0009 · Understanding USAG Gymnastics Levels: A Complete Guide (2024)

GPT-5.1 · Better

WIDE

Rounds

2 - 0

Final Score

124,150

Tokens

$1.24

Cost

Onboarding R2

Mode

← Back to battles·View source page·onboarding_battles/R2_gpt-5.1-search_vs_claude-opus-4.6-search_tree_0009.log

Timeline

Arrow keys or j/k move between rounds.

Round 1 of 5

Round Context

Depth 2Width 2Backtrack

Logic Chain

Root

Understanding USAG Gymnastics Levels: A Complete Guide (2024)

Step 2

Contact

Question

A Northeastern U.S.-based gymnastics organization referenced in guides explaining the USA Gymnastics (USAG) level progression offers athlete evaluations, multiple competitive team pathways (including in-house and travel options), and several physical gym locations. Identify this organization and provide a complete list of all its gym locations, including city, state, phone number, street address, and contact email. Additionally, summarize the structure and training expectations of each of its three distinct team program pathways, highlighting how they differ in competitiveness and weekly time commitment.

Answer length: 200-300 words.

Show hidden checklists

Depth checklist

Gold Medal Gymnastics & Ninja (also known as GMGC) correctly identified as the organization that offers USAG Development/Junior Olympic pathways and multiple Northeast locations
Recognition that the three team pathways are Club Team (local in-house), USA-IGC travel program, and Junior Olympic Program, distinguished by commitment level and competition structure

Width checklist

Centereach, NY location – correct phone number, full street address, and email
Garden City, NY location – correct phone number, full street address, and email
Huntington, NY location – correct phone number, full street address, and email
Levittown, NY location – correct phone number, full street address, and email
Rocky Point, NY location – correct phone number, full street address, and email
Short Hills, NJ location – correct phone number, full street address, and email
Smithtown, NY location – correct phone number, full street address, and email
Description of the Club Team (in-house, non-travel, limited pressure, internal competitions)
Description of the USA-IGC travel program (2–3 days/week, lower pressure, allows other activities, state/regional/national championships)
Description of the Junior Olympic Program (3–5 days/week depending on level, higher commitment, prohibits other sports, USAG competition structure)

Examiner rationale

The question uses logical cues from USAG level progression (Deep) to indirectly identify the specific gymnastics organization without naming it. It then requires broad aggregation (Wide) by demanding full contact details for every gym location plus a structured comparison of all three team programs, ensuring the respondent must compile and synthesize information from multiple sections of the organization’s public materials.

Judgment

Tie

BOTH

Score 0 - 0

Deep Logic Check: Both agents failed to identify the correct organization (Gold Medal Gymnastics & Ninja / GMGC). Agent A named Daggett Gymnastics (MA/CT), and Agent B named Gymnastics Empire (CT), neither of which matches the Northeastern NY/NJ organization in the checklist. Width/Completeness: Because the core entity is incorrect, all listed locations, contact details, and team pathway descriptions are also incorrect relative to the ground truth. Neither response includes any of the required NY/NJ locations (Centereach, Garden City, Huntington, Levittown, Rocky Point, Short Hills, Smithtown) or the specified Club Team / USA-IGC / Junior Olympic distinctions. Presentation: Both are reasonably formatted, but formatting cannot compensate for factual inaccuracy. Since both fail both Deep and Wide criteria with significant hallucinations, this is a Low Quality Tie.

Evolution step

Determining Next Step...

TIE (Both Bad): BACKTRACKING.

[BACKTRACK] Moving up to Parent Node

GPT-5.1

OpenAI

7.6s

The organization is Daggett Gymnastics, based in Massachusetts. It operates the following locations: 1. **Daggett Gymnastics – Agawam, MA** - Address: 145 Old Springfield Rd, Agawam, MA 01001 - Phone: (413) 786-4686 - Email: daggett@daggettgym.com [1][2] 2. **Daggett Gymnastics – Westfield, MA** - Address: 157 Doty Circle, Westfield, MA 01085 - Phone: (413) 562-9357 - Email: westfield@daggettgym.com [1][3] 3. **Daggett Gymnastics – Enfield, CT** - Address: 1559 King St, Enfield, CT 06082 - Phone: (860) 265-3822 - Email: enfield@daggettgym.com [1][4] Daggett describes three primary competitive pathways: - **In‑House / Invitational Team**: Designed for athletes who enjoy competition with a lower time and financial commitment. Training is typically a few days per week, focusing on skill development and local or in‑house meets rather than high‑stakes competition. [2][5] - **Travel / Competitive Team (USAG JO/DP)**: For athletes pursuing a more traditional and competitive USAG Development Program track. Gymnasts train more hours per week (often 3–5 days, multiple hours per session) with expectations for consistent attendance, conditioning, and participation in regional travel meets. [2][5] - **Xcel / Alternative Competitive Pathway**: Offers a flexible, competitive option balancing other activities with gymnastics. Training time is moderate—more than in‑house but less than top JO/DP levels—with routines tailored to athlete strengths and a mix of local and some travel competitions. Emphasis is on enjoyment, progression, and manageable commitment. [2][5] ## References [1] https://www.daggettgymnastics.com [2] https://www.daggettgymnastics.com/team-programs [3] https://www.daggettgymnastics.com/westfield [4] https://www.daggettgymnastics.com/enfield [5] https://www.daggettgymnastics.com/teams

Claude Opus 4.6

Anthropic

14.4s

The organization is **Gymnastics Empire** (Empire Gymnastics), based in the Northeastern United States, frequently referenced in guides explaining USAG level progression [1][2]. ## Gym Locations 1. **Newtown, CT** – 11 Queen Street, Newtown, CT 06470 | Phone: (203) 426-0700 | Email: info@gymnasticsempire.com [3] 2. **Danbury, CT** – 21 Shelter Rock Lane, Danbury, CT 06810 | Phone: (203) 826-8257 | Email: danbury@gymnasticsempire.com [3] 3. **Bethel, CT** – 55 Stony Hill Road, Bethel, CT 06801 | Phone: (203) 739-3340 | Email: bethel@gymnasticsempire.com [3] ## Three Team Program Pathways **1. In-House Competition Team (Prep Team)** This entry-level pathway is designed for athletes beginning their competitive journey. Athletes train approximately 2–4 hours per week and compete at in-house meets and local invitationals. The focus is on building foundational skills, confidence, and introducing gymnasts to competition structure in a supportive, low-pressure environment [1][2]. **2. Travel Competitive Team (Compulsory/Optional Levels)** This pathway follows the USAG level progression (Levels 2–10) and involves regional and state travel meets. Athletes train approximately 6–16+ hours per week depending on level, with increasing expectations as gymnasts advance. This track demands greater commitment, consistency, and skill mastery, preparing athletes for sanctioned USAG competitions [1][2]. **3. Xcel Team Program** The Xcel program offers a flexible competitive alternative to the traditional USAG level track. Athletes compete at Bronze through Diamond divisions, training roughly 4–8 hours per week. It provides meaningful competition with a modified time commitment, ideal for gymnasts seeking competitive experience without the intensity of the traditional track [1][2]. Athlete evaluations are conducted to place gymnasts in the pathway best suited to their skill level and goals [2]. ## References 1. Gymnastics Empire – Team Programs, https://www.gymnasticsempire.com/teams 2. Gymnastics Empire – USAG Level Guide, https://www.gymnasticsempire.com/usag-levels 3. Gymnastics Empire – Locations & Contact, https://www.gymnasticsempire.com/locations