Kimi K2 vs GLM-4.7
tree_0002 · Mac User Guide
Timeline
Arrow keys or j/k move between rounds.
Round Context
Mac User Guide
Sales Policies
Based on the sales policies for the Apple Consumer Store in Singapore, compare the return constraints—specifically regarding return location, time limits, and restocking fees—for 'custom third-party prescription optical inserts' versus 'volume purchases' (defined as an aggregate of more than four items). Additionally, explain the specific eligibility criteria and exclusions for claiming a refund if the price of a purchased product is reduced shortly after delivery.
Answer length: 200-300 words.
Show hidden checklists
- Identify 'ZEISS Optical Inserts - Prescription' as the specific third-party product with unique return restrictions (distinct from 'Readers' or standard products).
- Identify 'Return of Products Purchased in Volume' section to extract the 25% fee and 7-day limit logic.
- Confirm the context is specific to the 'Singapore Consumer Store' (e.g., noting the Singapore-specific policy nuances if applicable, though the rules provided are the key).
- Prescription Inserts: Must be returned online or via phone (cannot be returned to an Apple Store location).
- Prescription Inserts: Return window is within 14 days of receipt.
- Volume Purchases: Return window is within 7 days of receipt.
- Volume Purchases: Subject to a 25% restocking fee per item.
- Volume Purchases: Must be returned to the specific Apple Store where originally purchased.
- Price Protection: Refund available if price drops within 14 calendar days of receipt.
- Price Protection: Excludes limited-time price reductions or special sales events.
- Price Protection: Limited to up to 10 units of a particular product.
The question utilizes Deep Reasoning by describing the entities ('custom third-party prescription optical inserts' and 'volume purchases') rather than naming the specific policy headers (ZEISS, Volume Policy). This forces the agent to map the descriptions to the correct sections of the text. The Wide Aggregation is achieved by requiring the agent to synthesize information from three distinct sections of the policy document: the specific exception for ZEISS Prescription inserts, the strict rules for Volume returns, and the separate Price Reduction clause, contrasting their differing deadlines (14 days vs 7 days) and fees (0% vs 25%).
Judgment
Both agents failed the Deep Logic/Accuracy check significantly. Both agents incorrectly stated that 'Custom Prescription Inserts' and 'Volume Purchases' are completely non-returnable. The Ground Truth checklist explicitly states that Inserts are returnable (online/phone only) and Volume Purchases are returnable (subject to a 25% fee and 7-day window). However, Agent A is the winner solely based on User Experience and Formatting. Agent A provided a clean, professional, and readable response with proper inline citations. Agent B, conversely, included raw internal tool logs (JSON search queries) and chain-of-thought text in the final output, making the response messy and difficult to read. Since both failed on facts, the agent with the usable interface wins.
Kimi K2
Moonshot AI
GLM-4.7
Zhipu AI