Gemini 3.1 Pro vs GPT-5.1
tree_0009 · Understanding USAG Gymnastics Levels: A Complete Guide (2024)
Timeline
Arrow keys or j/k move between rounds.
Round Context
Understanding USAG Gymnastics Levels: A Complete Guide (2024)
Contact
A gymnastics organization referenced in a 2024 guide to the USA Gymnastics (USAG) level system operates seven training centers across New York and New Jersey to support athletes from developmental through Elite levels. Identify all seven of these locations and provide, for each one, its full street address, phone number, and contact email. Additionally, for the Long Island facility described as being located in a red brick building near a well-known bull statue, provide its regular hours of operation and summarize the main categories of classes and programs offered there.
Answer length: 200-300 words.
Show hidden checklists
- Centereach, NY – verified as one of the seven official training centers operated by the organization
- Garden City, NY – verified as one of the seven official training centers operated by the organization
- Huntington, NY – verified as one of the seven official training centers operated by the organization
- Levittown, NY – verified as one of the seven official training centers operated by the organization
- Rocky Point, NY – verified as one of the seven official training centers operated by the organization
- Short Hills, NJ – verified as the New Jersey branch among the seven locations
- Smithtown, NY – identified via the red brick building near the Smithtown bull statue and confirmed as one of the seven locations
- Centereach location – full street address
- Centereach location – phone number
- Centereach location – email address
- Garden City location – full street address
- Garden City location – phone number
- Garden City location – email address
- Huntington location – full street address
- Huntington location – phone number
- Huntington location – email address
- Levittown location – full street address
- Levittown location – phone number
- Levittown location – email address
- Rocky Point location – full street address
- Rocky Point location – phone number
- Rocky Point location – email address
- Short Hills, NJ location – full street address
- Short Hills, NJ location – phone number
- Short Hills, NJ location – email address
- Smithtown location – full street address
- Smithtown location – phone number
- Smithtown location – email address
- Smithtown location – regular hours of operation (weekday and weekend)
- Smithtown location – summary of program categories (e.g., preschool, recreational, advanced/competitive, ninja, tumbling, private/exclusive programs)
The question uses the USAG level guide context to anchor the organization without referencing the source document (Deep). It masks the specific locations by requiring identification of all seven centers and indirectly referencing Smithtown through a landmark clue. It then requires aggregation of contact details for every site plus additional operational and program information for one specific facility, ensuring broad cross-page verification (Wide).
Judgment
Deep Logic: Agent A correctly identified Gold Medal Gymnastics Centers (GMGC) as the organization and listed mostly correct NY locations, including Smithtown as the red-brick/bull statue site. However, A substituted Greenlawn for the required Short Hills, NJ location, creating a factual omission. Agent B failed Deep Logic entirely by identifying a different organization (NYC Elite/Diamond Gymnastics network), which does not match the seven-center NY/NJ structure in the prompt. Width/Completeness: Agent A provided structured address, phone, and email details for most required locations and included Smithtown’s hours and program categories. However, it omitted Short Hills, NJ and instead listed Greenlawn, resulting in a checklist failure. Agent B missed nearly all required checklist items (wrong centers, wrong geography, incorrect Long Island identification), so it failed both depth and width. Presentation & UX: Agent A was clearly formatted, scannable, and organized with numbered locations and a dedicated Smithtown section. Agent B was structured but irrelevant to the query’s actual entity, making it unhelpful despite formatting. Conclusion: Agent A is factually flawed but substantially closer to the correct entity and requested data. Because A contains a concrete location error (missing Short Hills, NJ), the verdict is capped at BETTER rather than MUCH_BETTER.
Gemini 3.1 Pro
GPT-5.1
OpenAI