Battle replay

Claude Opus 4.6 vs GPT-5.1

tree_0015 · Contact Lenses: Types and How They Work

GPT-5.1 · Much Better

BOTH

Rounds

2 - 5

Final Score

241,302

Tokens

$2.41

Cost

Onboarding R2

Mode

← Back to battles·View source page·onboarding_battles/R2_claude-opus-4.6-search_vs_gpt-5.1-search_tree_0015.log

Timeline

Arrow keys or j/k move between rounds.

Round 1 of 9

Round Context

Depth 2Width 2Increase width

Logic Chain

Root

Contact Lenses: Types and How They Work

Step 2

Institutes & Departments

Question

When researching contact lenses and how they work, a reader learns that getting an annual eye exam at a major nonprofit academic medical center in Ohio is recommended to detect vision problems early. Focusing on this same institution, identify: (1) the resource that provides a comprehensive guide to all of its departments, institutes, and clinical services, and explain what breadth of information it offers; and (2) its virtual second opinion program, describing in detail how the process works (including key steps from intake to final report), the available service tiers and pricing, its policies regarding insurance and Medicare coverage, U.S. state availability and exclusions, and the cost and country restrictions for international patients.

Answer length: 200-300 words.

Show hidden checklists

Depth checklist

Cleveland Clinic – Identified as the major nonprofit academic medical center in Ohio recommending annual eye exams
Cleveland Clinic Departments/Institutes/Services Guide – Official comprehensive listing of all departments and services
Virtual Second Opinions by Cleveland Clinic (delivered by The Clinic, a joint venture with Amwell) – Matches the described multi-step remote second opinion service

Width checklist

Description of the comprehensive guide covering all departments, institutes, and services within the organization
Explanation that the guide spans clinical specialties and service lines across the health system
Name and overview of the Virtual Second Opinion program
Step 1: Registration and live intake visit with a nurse care manager
Step 2: Medical record collection and expedited specialist matching
Step 3: Delivery of a written expert report and optional virtual visit
Two pricing tiers (written report only vs. report + virtual visit) with specific U.S. prices
Statement that insurance typically does not cover the service and that Medicare is not billed
Details about U.S. state availability, including states where service is not offered
International patient cost (USD) and list of excluded countries

Examiner rationale

The question uses the clue about annual eye exams (deep logic) to anchor the search to Cleveland Clinic without initially naming the specific service pages. It then requires broad aggregation (wide logic) by asking for detailed, multi-part information about two distinct institutional resources: the comprehensive departments/services guide and the Virtual Second Opinions program, including process steps, pricing, coverage, and geographic restrictions.

Judgment

Better

WIDE

Score 0 - 1

Both agents correctly identified Cleveland Clinic (DEEP logic passed). However, Agent A relied on the older MyConsult program with outdated pricing ($749/$1,199) and did not describe the current Virtual Second Opinion structure delivered with The Clinic by Cleveland Clinic. It also omitted key required details: live intake visit with a nurse care manager, expedited specialist matching, optional virtual visit tier, specific state exclusions, and detailed international restrictions—failing multiple WIDTH checklist items. Agent B correctly referenced the modern Virtual Second Opinion model, included the nurse care manager intake step, specialist matching, written report, optional telehealth tier, self-pay policy (no Medicare billing), example excluded states, and higher international pricing. While B used price ranges and did not list specific excluded countries, it was far more aligned with the required program details and provided a clearer, more comprehensive user experience. Therefore, B is better on completeness and accuracy.

Evolution step

Determining Next Step...

WINNER is B. Targeting Loser Failure: WIDE.

Action: Wide+1 (Increase Context Width)

Claude Opus 4.6

Anthropic

14.5s

Cleveland Clinic, a major nonprofit academic medical center in Ohio, is widely recommended for annual eye exams to detect vision problems early [1]. **(1) Comprehensive Guide to Departments and Services:** Cleveland Clinic's **Health Library and institutional directory** serves as a comprehensive guide to all its departments, institutes, and clinical services. Specifically, its "Institutes & Departments" resource provides an A-to-Z listing covering over 27 institutes, numerous departments, and hundreds of clinical services spanning specialties from cardiology and ophthalmology to neurology, cancer care, and pediatrics. This resource offers breadth of information including condition descriptions, treatment options, physician directories, appointment scheduling, and patient education materials [2]. **(2) MyConsult Virtual Second Opinion Program:** Cleveland Clinic's **MyConsult Online Medical Second Opinion** program allows patients to obtain expert opinions remotely [3]. **Process:** Patients begin by completing an online intake questionnaire detailing their diagnosis and medical history. They then upload or mail relevant medical records, imaging, and pathology materials. A Cleveland Clinic specialist reviews all documentation and prepares a comprehensive written report, typically delivered within 7–10 business days, containing a diagnosis confirmation or revision and treatment recommendations [3][4]. **Service Tiers and Pricing:** The standard medical second opinion costs **$749**. A premium **Executive Medical Second Opinion** with expedited service is available for **$1,199** [4]. **Insurance and Medicare:** MyConsult is generally **not covered by insurance or Medicare**, and patients pay out-of-pocket [3][4]. **U.S. Availability:** The service is available in most U.S. states but is **excluded in certain states** due to regulatory restrictions, with specific exclusions varying [4]. **International Patients:** International patients can access MyConsult at a cost of **$1,199**, though the service may be restricted in certain countries due to regulatory or sanctions-related limitations [3][4]. ## References 1. Cleveland Clinic. "Eye Exams: Why They're Important." https://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/diagnostics/eye-exam 2. Cleveland Clinic. "Institutes & Departments." https://my.clevelandclinic.org/departments 3. Cleveland Clinic. "MyConsult Online Medical Second Opinion." https://my.clevelandclinic.org/online-services/myconsult 4. Cleveland Clinic. "MyConsult FAQ and Pricing." https://my.clevelandclinic.org/online-services/myconsult/pricing

GPT-5.1

OpenAI

20.4s

The institution is Cleveland Clinic. 1. **Comprehensive guide to departments and services** Cleveland Clinic’s primary resource is its “Institutes & Departments” directory on the main website, which links to every clinical institute (e.g., Cole Eye Institute), department, and center, plus related clinical services, locations, and programs.[1] It provides overviews of each institute’s specialties, conditions treated, diagnostic and treatment options, physician/provider profiles, appointment options (in-person, virtual), patient education materials, and access to research and clinical trial information.[1] This functions as a system-wide guide to all major service lines. 2. **Virtual Second Opinion program** Cleveland Clinic’s Virtual Second Opinion (often branded with The Clinic by Cleveland Clinic) lets patients upload records for a remote expert review.[2] Typical steps: online intake and eligibility screening; secure account creation and consent; dedicated nurse care manager collects medical records and imaging; case is matched to a Cleveland Clinic specialist; physician reviews records (and may request more information); a detailed written second-opinion report is produced and shared with the patient and, if requested, the local doctor.[2][3] For U.S. patients, standard pricing is about $1,850–$1,950 for a written second opinion; some packages include an optional telehealth visit at higher cost tiers.[2][3] The service is self-pay: commercial insurance and Medicare/Medicaid generally do not cover it.[2] Availability excludes certain U.S. states (commonly Alaska, Hawaii, Maine, New Mexico, Vermont, and U.S. territories) due to regulatory limits.[2] International patients can access the program for a higher fee (around $2,000–$2,500), must pay out-of-pocket, and it is available only in select countries where telehealth regulations permit cross-border second opinions.[2][3] ## References [1] Cleveland Clinic – Institutes & Departments directory [2] Cleveland Clinic / The Clinic by Cleveland Clinic – Virtual Second Opinion program pages [3] Cleveland Clinic – FAQs and pricing details for Virtual Second Opinion