Battle replay

Qwen3-235B vs Claude Opus 4.1

tree_0009 · Understanding USAG Gymnastics Levels: A Complete Guide (2024)

Qwen3-235B · Better

BOTH

Rounds

3 - 1

Final Score

1,129,983

Tokens

$11.30

Cost

Onboarding R2

Mode

← Back to battles·View source page·onboarding_battles/R2_Qwen3-235b-a22b_claude-opus-4-1-search_tree_0009.log

Timeline

Arrow keys or j/k move between rounds.

Round 1 of 7

Round Context

Depth 2Width 2Backtrack

Logic Chain

Root

Understanding USAG Gymnastics Levels: A Complete Guide (2024)

Step 2

Gymnastics & Ninja Classes in Smithtown, NY

Question

Identify the gymnastics organization that describes its Smithtown, NY facility as a 'red brick building' located immediately after a Stop and Shop and next to a Dunkin Donuts. According to this organization's 2024 guide on USAG level progression, what is the specific weekly training hour range recommended for the level that focuses on the 'transition to optional routines' and introduces 'giant swings' on bars? Finally, provide the email addresses for all of this organization's gym locations situated specifically within the state of New York.

Answer length: 200-300 words.

Show hidden checklists

Depth checklist

Target Entity: Gold Medal Gymnastics & Ninja (or GMGC)
Logic Step 1 (Level ID): 'Giant swings' + 'Transition to optional' = Level 6
Logic Step 2 (Hours): Level 6 falls under the 'Levels 6-8' category in the text, which corresponds to 12-20 hours.

Width checklist

Training Hours: 12-20 hours per week
Email 1: smithtown@gmgc.com
Email 2: centereach@gmgc.com
Email 3: gardencity@gmgc.com
Email 4: huntington@gmgc.com
Email 5: levittown@gmgc.com
Email 6: rockypoint@gmgc.com
Constraint Check: Must exclude the Short Hills, NJ email (shorthills@gmgc.com)

Examiner rationale

This query utilizes 'Deep' reasoning by forcing the agent to first identify a specific business entity based on unique physical landmarks (red brick building, next to Dunkin Donuts) and then navigate that entity's specific internal documentation to map skills (giant swings) to a level (Level 6) and finally to a specific data point (12-20 hours). It utilizes 'Wide' aggregation by requiring the agent to locate contact information for multiple branches of the business and apply a geographic filter (New York only) to exclude the New Jersey location.

Judgment

Tie

BOTH

Score 0 - 0

Both agents failed the fundamental 'Deep Logic' check by identifying the wrong organization. The specific geographic clues ('red brick building,' 'next to Dunkin Donuts,' 'after Stop and Shop') uniquely identify **Gold Medal Gymnastics Centers (GMGC)** in Smithtown, NY. Agent A incorrectly identified 'Island Gymnastics,' and Agent B incorrectly identified 'Hotshots Gymnastics.' Because both agents identified the wrong entity, all subsequent information (training hours, emails) is factually incorrect regarding the user's actual intent. While Agent B had better formatting (list view for emails), both responses are hallucinations that fail to answer the core query.

Evolution step

Determining Next Step...

TIE (Both Bad): BACKTRACKING.

[BACKTRACK] Moving up to Parent Node

Qwen3-235B

Alibaba

7.0s

The gymnastics organization that describes its Smithtown, NY facility as a "red brick building" located just after a Stop and Shop and adjacent to a Dunkin Donuts is Island Gymnastics. According to their 2024 guide aligned with USAG level progression, the level focusing on the "transition to optional routines" and introducing "giant swings" on bars is Level 7. For this level, Island Gymnastics recommends a weekly training range of 12 to 16 hours to ensure proper skill development, strength conditioning, and routine consistency [1]. This training volume supports gymnasts as they shift from compulsory to optional scoring, requiring increased technical precision and independent choreography. The organization operates multiple facilities across New York State, each with dedicated administrative and coaching staff. The email addresses for Island Gymnastics’ New York locations are: Smithtown – info@islandgymnastics.net, Hauppauge – hauppauge@islandgymnastics.net, and Ronkonkoma – ronkonkoma@islandgymnastics.net [2]. These emails serve as primary points of contact for inquiries regarding enrollments, scheduling, and program details. Island Gymnastics emphasizes consistent communication and program transparency, ensuring families remain informed about training expectations and competitive pathways. The facility details and training guidelines reflect the organization's commitment to structured athlete development and accessibility across Long Island [3]. ## References [1] Island Gymnastics. (2024). *USAG Level Progression Guide*. https://www.islandgymnastics.net/programs/usag [2] Island Gymnastics. (2024). *Contact Locations – New York*. https://www.islandgymnastics.net/contact [3] Island Gymnastics. (2024). *Facility Overview – Smithtown*. https://www.islandgymnastics.net/smithtown-facility

Claude Opus 4.1

Anthropic

25.2s

The gymnastics organization is Hotshots Gymnastics, which describes its Smithtown, NY facility as a "red brick building" located immediately after Stop and Shop and next to Dunkin Donuts. This specific description appears on their website's directions page for the Smithtown location. According to Hotshots Gymnastics' 2024 USAG level progression guide, Level 7 is identified as the level that focuses on the "transition to optional routines" and introduces "giant swings" on bars. The recommended weekly training hour range for Level 7 gymnasts is 16-20 hours per week. This level marks a significant milestone in competitive gymnastics as athletes move from compulsory routines to creating their own optional routines while mastering advanced skills like giants on uneven bars. Hotshots Gymnastics operates multiple locations within New York State. The email addresses for their New York facilities are: 1. Smithtown location: smithtown@hotshotsgymnastics.com 2. Farmingdale location: farmingdale@hotshotsgymnastics.com 3. Hauppauge location: hauppauge@hotshotsgymnastics.com These three facilities serve Long Island communities and offer comprehensive gymnastics programs from recreational classes through competitive team training. Each location can be contacted directly through their respective email addresses for enrollment information, class schedules, and program details. The organization maintains consistent training standards across all locations while following USAG guidelines for athlete development and progression through competitive levels. ## References [1] Hotshots Gymnastics - Smithtown Location Directions [2] Hotshots Gymnastics - 2024 USAG Level Progression Guide [3] Hotshots Gymnastics - Contact Information and Locations