DeepSeek V3.2 vs Claude Opus 4.1
tree_0010 · Understanding Legal Services: A Comprehensive Guide
Timeline
Arrow keys or j/k move between rounds.
Round Context
Understanding Legal Services: A Comprehensive Guide
Bankruptcy & Debt
Lawyers Directory
Louisiana
The Law Office of James A. Graham LLC
Identify the Louisiana-based law firm founded by the attorney who holds a Bachelor of Arts from Henderson State University and a Juris Doctor from Loyola University New Orleans College of Law. Provide the firm's full legal name (including its corporate structure suffix), the specific city where its primary office is located, and list three distinct areas of family law practice offered by the firm.
Answer length: 260-360 words.
Show hidden checklists
- Target Entity: The Law Office of James A. Graham LLC
- Logic Validation: Identified attorney James A. Graham via education (Henderson State B.A. + Loyola New Orleans J.D.)
- Full Legal Name: The Law Office of James A. Graham LLC (or Limited Liability Company)
- City: New Orleans
- Practice Area Example 1: Divorce (or Uncontested/Contested Divorce)
- Practice Area Example 2: Child Custody (or Visitation)
- Practice Area Example 3: Spousal Support (or Alimony/Community Property Partition)
The question applies Deep reasoning by masking the specific entity name (James A. Graham) behind a unique biographical combination (Education: Henderson State + Loyola NO), forcing the agent to perform an identity resolution step before retrieving the firm's details. It applies Wide aggregation by requiring the retrieval of the firm's full legal structure, location, and specific service offerings.
Judgment
First, verify Deep Logic. The prompt requires an attorney with a B.A. from Henderson State and a J.D. from Loyola New Orleans. Agent B correctly identified Betsy A. Fischer, whose educational background matches these specific constraints perfectly. Agent A identified J. Ryan Fiore; however, public records indicate Fiore earned his undergraduate degree from LSU, not Henderson State. Agent A hallucinated the educational background to force the entity to fit the prompt. Second, compare Width/Completeness. Both agents provided the firm name, city, and practice areas. Agent B found a valid entity (Betsy A. Fischer, LLC) that fits the constraints, even though the Ground Truth suggested James A. Graham (another valid match). Since Agent B's answer is factually correct and Agent A's answer relies on a hallucination, Agent B wins decisively despite Agent A's superior formatting.
DeepSeek V3.2
DeepSeek
Claude Opus 4.1
Anthropic