o3 vs GPT-5.1
tree_0029 · Handball
Timeline
Arrow keys or j/k move between rounds.
Round Context
Handball
Чемпионат России по гандболу среди мужчин — Википедия
In the history of the Russian Men's Handball Championship (Super League) through the 2023/24 season, three distinct Moscow-based entities have each claimed the gold medal exactly twice. Identify these three specific clubs, distinguishing between historical iterations that are statistically treated as separate entities. For each club, provide: (1) the specific seasons in which they won the championship, and (2) the total number of silver medals they have secured, ensuring to aggregate records from immediate predecessor clubs (such as those rebranded in 2020) where officially recognized.
Answer length: 200-300 words.
Show hidden checklists
- Identify CSKA (Moscow) [1969-1998 iteration]
- Identify CSKA-Sportakadem (Moscow) [Distinct from old CSKA and Chekhovskie Medvedi]
- Identify CSKA (Moscow) [Est. 2017 iteration, formerly Spartak]
- Entity 1 (1990s Era): Won seasons 1993/94 and 1994/95
- Entity 1 Silver Count: 0 (Zero)
- Entity 2 (Turn of Millennium): Won seasons 1999/00 and 2000/01
- Entity 2 Silver Count: 0 (Zero)
- Entity 3 (Modern Era): Won seasons 2022/23 and 2023/24
- Entity 3 Silver Count: 4 (Includes 2 as Spartak and 2 as CSKA up to 2024)
This question uses Deep Logic by filtering for 'Moscow-based' and 'Exactly Two Wins', which forces the agent to distinguish between three similarly named but distinct legal entities (Old CSKA, CSKA-Sportakadem, New CSKA) while excluding the dominant 'Chekhovskie Medvedi'. It requires Wide Aggregation to correctly sum the silver medals for the modern CSKA by linking it to its former identity, 'Spartak', and retrieving specific historical seasons for all three.
Judgment
Agent B experienced a critical technical failure (API Error) and provided no response, which is an automatic loss against a functioning agent. Agent A provided a structured, well-formatted response that adhered to the length constraints. However, Agent A failed significantly on the 'Accuracy' dimension. It failed the 'Deep Logic' check by misidentifying the three entities (hallucinating Spartak and Dynamo as gold medalists, when the correct answer involves three distinct historical iterations of CSKA/CSKA-Sportakadem). It also failed the 'Wide' checks by citing incorrect years and medal counts. Despite these severe factual hallucinations, Agent A is rated 'Better' solely because it attempted the task, whereas Agent B failed completely.
o3
OpenAI
GPT-5.1
OpenAI