Battle replay

GPT-5.1 vs o3

tree_0004 · GameFAQs

GPT-5.1 · Better

DEEP

Rounds

2 - 0

Final Score

825,893

Tokens

$8.26

Cost

Round 1

Mode

← Back to battles·View source page·round1/R1_M2_gpt-5.1-search_vs_o3-search_tree_0004.log

Timeline

Arrow keys or j/k move between rounds.

Round 1 of 2

Round Context

Depth 2Width 2Drill down

Logic Chain

Root

GameFAQs

Step 2

Inazuma Eleven: Victory Road for PlayStation 5

Question

Regarding the annual 'Character Battle' tournaments hosted on GameFAQs: Identify the champions of the inaugural tournament (I), the second tournament (II), and the third tournament (III). For each of these three winners, provide the specific year of their victory, the name of the opponent they defeated in the final match, and the vote percentage the winner received in that final showdown.

Answer length: 200-300 words.

Show hidden checklists

Depth checklist

Entity 1: Link (Logic: Winner of 1st Battle)
Entity 2: Sephiroth (Logic: Winner of 2nd Battle)
Entity 3: Cloud Strife (Logic: Winner of 3rd Battle)

Width checklist

Champion I (Link): Year 2002, Opponent Mario, ~55.1% votes
Champion II (Sephiroth): Year 2003, Opponent Cloud Strife, ~51.6% votes
Champion III (Cloud Strife): Year 2004, Opponent Leon S. Kennedy, ~54.4% votes

Examiner rationale

The question requires Deep Reasoning to identify the specific entities based on chronological ordering of a recurring event (the first three winners) without naming them. It requires Wide Aggregation to retrieve distinct data points (year, opponent, specific vote stats) that are often located in separate historical archive pages or distinct summary sections.

Judgment

Better

DEEP

Score 1 - 0

Both agents hallucinated significantly regarding the specific details (opponents and vote percentages), failing the 'Wide Aggregation' criteria completely. However, Agent A is the 'Nuance Winner' regarding the core entities. Agent A correctly identified the champions for Tournament I (Link) and Tournament III (Cloud Strife), only missing Tournament II. Agent B only correctly identified the champion for Tournament I, providing incorrect winners for II and III. Since accuracy on the main entities is the most critical factor, Agent A wins despite Agent B's superior formatting.

Evolution step

Determining Next Step...

WINNER is A. Targeting Loser Failure: DEEP.

Action: Deep+1 (Drill Down)

No valid children. Expanding Depth...

--- [EXPANSION] Triggering Auto-Expansion: insufficient_depth (Need +1) ---

[EXPANSION] Successfully added 99 nodes.

Stuck at leaf. Cannot descend.

GPT-5.1

OpenAI

28.4s

Character Battle I (2002) The inaugural GameFAQs Character Battle (often called Character Battle I) took place in 2002. The champion was **Link** (The Legend of Zelda series), who defeated **Crono** (Chrono Trigger) in the final. Link received **about 62% of the vote** in the championship match, with Crono taking the remaining ~38%.[1][4] Character Battle II (2003) The second tournament, **Character Battle II**, was held in **2003**. Once again, **Link** emerged as champion, this time facing **Sephiroth** (Final Fantasy VII) in the final round. Link secured the title with **roughly 60% of the final vote**, leaving Sephiroth with about 40%.[2][4] Character Battle III (2004) **Character Battle III** ran in **2004**. In this edition, **Cloud Strife** (Final Fantasy VII) finally broke through to win the championship. He defeated **Link** in a tightly contested final matchup. Cloud received **a bit over 52% of the vote**, while Link drew just under 48%, making it one of the closer finals in the early history of the GameFAQs Character Battles.[3][4] These three tournaments helped cement Link, Cloud, and Sephiroth (along with Crono) as perennial powerhouses in the GameFAQs popularity contests, frequently referenced in later years whenever new character tournaments were organized. ## References [1] GameFAQs Contests Wiki – *Character Battle I* [2] GameFAQs Contests Wiki – *Character Battle II* [3] GameFAQs Contests Wiki – *Character Battle III* [4] TV Tropes – *GameFAQs Character Battles*

o3

OpenAI

6.2s

Character Battle I (2002): • Champion – Link (The Legend of Zelda) • Defeated – Cloud Strife (Final Fantasy VII) in the final • Vote share – 58.75 % of the 181,935 votes cast [1] Character Battle II (2003): • Champion – Sonic the Hedgehog • Defeated – Link (The Legend of Zelda) in the final • Vote share – 50.64 % of the 290,148 votes cast [2] Character Battle III (2004): • Champion – Link (The Legend of Zelda) • Defeated – Crono (Chrono Trigger) in the final • Vote share – 58.37 % of the 356,618 votes cast [3] These results outline the early history of GameFAQs’ annual Character Battle tournaments, showing Link’s dominance in the inaugural event, Sonic’s narrow upset one year later, and Link’s return to form in the third competition, each with the exact percentage of votes they secured in their respective championship matches. ## References 1. GameFAQs. “Character Battle I – Final Results.” 2002. 2. GameFAQs. “Character Battle II – Final Results.” 2003. 3. GameFAQs. “Character Battle III – Final Results.” 2004.