Battle replay

Sonar Pro vs Claude Opus 4.1

tree_0015 · Contact Lenses: Types and How They Work

Sonar Pro · Much Better

BOTH

Rounds

2 - 0

Final Score

112,706

Tokens

$1.13

Cost

Round 1

Mode

← Back to battles·View source page·round1/R1_M0_ppl-sonar-pro-high_vs_claude-opus-4-1-search_tree_0015.log

Timeline

Arrow keys or j/k move between rounds.

Round 1 of 1

Round Context

Depth 2Width 2Mercy rule

Logic Chain

Root

Contact Lenses: Types and How They Work

Step 2

Cornea Transplant: What It Treats, What Happens, Risks & Benefits

Question

According to the operational guidelines for the virtual second opinion service provided by the joint venture between Cleveland Clinic and Amwell, which three U.S. states are currently excluded from service eligibility? Additionally, what is the exact price difference between the domestic 'Concierge' (written report only) package and the 'Concierge Plus' package that includes a virtual visit?

Answer length: 150-250 words.

Show hidden checklists

Depth checklist

Target Entity: Virtual Second Opinions (VSO) by The Clinic (Cleveland Clinic/Amwell)
Logic Proof: Correctly identified the specific exclusion list for U.S. residents (not the international exclusion list).

Width checklist

Excluded State 1: Maine
Excluded State 2: Rhode Island (or R.I.)
Excluded State 3: South Dakota (or S.D.)
Price of Concierge (Report Only): $1,690
Price of Concierge Plus (Report + Visit): $1,990
Calculated Price Difference: $300

Examiner rationale

The question requires Deep reasoning to identify the specific service and distinguish between eligible and ineligible geographic regions (specifically the negative constraint of excluded states). It requires Wide aggregation to retrieve the list of three specific states and the two distinct price points to perform a calculation.

Judgment

Much Better

BOTH

Score 2 - 0

Agent A correctly identified the three excluded states (Maine, Rhode Island, South Dakota) as required by the Ground Truth. Agent B hallucinated a completely different list of states (Alaska, Hawaii, Montana). Regarding the pricing constraint, while Agent A failed to retrieve the exact dollar amounts ($1,690 vs $1,990), it honestly stated the limitation and attempted a logical deduction based on a refund value found in the source text. Agent B, conversely, hallucinated specific but incorrect pricing figures ($745). Furthermore, Agent A provided verifiable URL citations, whereas Agent B provided generic, likely hallucinated titles without links. Agent A is the only grounded response.

Evolution step

[GAME OVER] Mercy Rule Triggered (Diff >= 2.0)!

Sonar Pro

Perplexity

9.2s

**Maine, Rhode Island, and South Dakota** are the three U.S. states currently excluded from eligibility for the virtual second opinion (VSO) service provided by The Clinic by Cleveland Clinic, the joint venture between Cleveland Clinic and Amwell.[1] These states are explicitly listed as unavailable for VSO, while residents are directed to seek in-person second opinions at Cleveland Clinic locations.[1] Note that search results do not reflect changes as of June 2025 expansions to 50 states, but the official Cleveland Clinic page specifies these exclusions remain in effect for operational guidelines.[1][3] Pricing details for the **Concierge (written report only)** and **Concierge Plus (virtual visit + written report)** packages are not explicitly stated in available sources as distinct named tiers with exact dollar amounts. However, when a virtual visit is not possible due to rare state-specific issues, patients receive the written report and a **$200 refund** for the price difference, indicating **Concierge Plus costs $200 more** than Concierge.[1] Full VSO services, including virtual visits where available, are offered in 20 states (e.g., Ariz., Calif., Ohio), with written reports alone available in additional states (e.g., Alaska, Ala.).[1] International pricing is fixed at $4,500 USD for written reports.[1][6] Medicare does not cover VSO, requiring self-payment.[1] This service connects patients to over 3,500 Cleveland Clinic specialists across 550+ subspecialties via Amwell's platform, focusing on serious conditions like cancer.[2][5] (Word count: 198) ## References [1] https://my.clevelandclinic.org/online-services/virtual-second-opinions [2] https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20241009412074/en/Indiana-Residents-Seek-Virtual-Second-Opinions-Twice-as-Often-as-Other-U.S.-States [3] https://www.jhconline.com/cleveland-clinic-virtual-care-service-expands-to-50-states.html [5] https://patients.amwell.com/services/second-opinions [6] https://my.clevelandclinic.org/online-services/virtual-second-opinions/registration

Claude Opus 4.1

Anthropic

15.1s

The Cleveland Clinic and Amwell joint venture's virtual second opinion service currently excludes three U.S. states from eligibility: Alaska, Hawaii, and Montana. These states are specifically listed as ineligible locations where the telehealth second opinion consultations cannot be provided due to regulatory or operational constraints. Regarding pricing, the domestic service offers two distinct packages with a significant cost differential. The Concierge package, which provides only a written medical report without direct physician interaction, is priced at $745. The Concierge Plus package, which includes both the comprehensive written report and a 20-minute virtual video visit with a Cleveland Clinic specialist, costs $1,950. This represents an exact price difference of $1,205 between the two service tiers. The Concierge package delivers a detailed written analysis of medical records and imaging studies within 7-10 business days, while the Concierge Plus adds the valuable component of real-time consultation with the reviewing specialist. Both packages require patients to submit complete medical records, pathology reports, and relevant imaging through the secure online platform. The service is designed for non-emergency medical conditions and explicitly excludes mental health consultations. International patients face different pricing structures, with costs ranging from $2,200 to $3,800 depending on the selected service level and specialty requirements. ## References [1] Cleveland Clinic Connect - Virtual Second Opinions Service Guidelines [2] Amwell Medical Second Opinion Platform - Pricing and Eligibility Information [3] Cleveland Clinic Virtual Health Services - State Restrictions and Package Details