Battle replay

Kimi K2 vs Grok 4

tree_0015 · Contact Lenses: Types and How They Work

Kimi K2 · Better

WIDE

Rounds

2 - 0

Final Score

138,569

Tokens

$1.39

Cost

Onboarding R1

Mode

← Back to battles·View source page·onboarding_battles/R1_Kimi-k2_grok-4-search_tree_0015.log

Timeline

Arrow keys or j/k move between rounds.

Round 1 of 2

Round Context

Depth 2Width 2Increase width

Logic Chain

Root

Contact Lenses: Types and How They Work

Step 2

Virtual Second Opinions

Question

Identify the virtual second opinion service established as a joint venture between Amwell and a prominent Cleveland-based academic medical center. Based on the service's availability guidelines, list the three U.S. states where residents are currently ineligible for any version of this program. Furthermore, differentiate the geographic availability for the 'Concierge Plus' (video visit) option versus the 'Concierge' (written report only) option within the United States, and compare the specific financial cost of the 'written report only' package for a domestic patient versus an international patient, including the policy regarding Medicare reimbursement.

Answer length: 200-300 words.

Show hidden checklists

Depth checklist

Target Entity: Virtual Second Opinions (VSO) by The Clinic (Cleveland Clinic + Amwell)
Logic Proof: Connects the 'joint venture between Amwell and Cleveland Clinic' to the specific VSO service described

Width checklist

Identifies the three excluded U.S. states: Maine, Rhode Island (R.I.), and South Dakota (S.D.)
Distinguishes that 'Concierge Plus' (Video + Report) is available in specific states (e.g., AZ, CA, NY, OH, etc.) while others are restricted to 'Concierge' (Report Only)
States the cost for the domestic 'Concierge' (written report only) service is $1,690
States the cost for the international service is $4,500 USD
Confirms that Medicare is not accepted and the service is self-pay only

Examiner rationale

The question uses Deep Logic by masking the service name, describing it only through its corporate partnership (Amwell + Cleveland Clinic). It requires Wide Aggregation by asking the agent to process and categorize a long list of U.S. states into three distinct eligibility groups (Excluded, Video, Report Only) and retrieve scattered pricing/insurance details.

Judgment

Better

WIDE

Score 1 - 0

Both agents correctly identified the core entity ('The Clinic' by Cleveland Clinic and Amwell). However, both agents struggled to perfectly match the specific Ground Truth (GT) checklist regarding the excluded states and international pricing, likely due to the GT reflecting a specific snapshot in time or specific policy document (e.g., GT lists Maine, RI, SD; Agent A lists Alaska, Hawaii, Maine; Agent B lists Alaska, Hawaii, Louisiana). Agent A is the winner for two main reasons: 1. **Accuracy Nuance**: Agent A correctly identified 'Maine' as one of the excluded states (matching the GT), whereas Agent B missed all three GT states. 2. **Formatting & Experience**: Agent A provided a superior user experience by using bolding for key information (states, pricing, service tiers) and was more concise. Agent B presented the information as a 'wall of text' which is harder to scan. Both agents found the updated domestic price ($1,850) rather than the older GT price ($1,690), which is acceptable, but both missed the higher international price listed in the GT.

Evolution step

Determining Next Step...

WINNER is A. Targeting Loser Failure: WIDE.

Action: Wide+1 (Increase Context Width)

Kimi K2

Moonshot AI

131.3s

The **Cleveland Clinic Virtual Second Opinions** service is a joint venture between telehealth platform Amwell and Cleveland Clinic, a premier Cleveland-based academic medical center [1][2]. This program currently excludes residents of three states—**Alaska, Hawaii, and Maine**—due to state-specific telehealth licensing restrictions, making all service versions unavailable to patients in these locations [1][3]. Geographic availability varies markedly between the two service tiers. The **Concierge Plus** option, featuring a live video consultation with a Cleveland Clinic specialist, is limited to 31 U.S. states where the institution's physicians hold active telemedicine licenses [1][4]. Conversely, the **Concierge** tier, which provides only a comprehensive written report, is available in 47 states—effectively nationwide except for the three prohibited states—because it bypasses real-time licensing requirements [1][4]. Regarding pricing for the written report package, domestic U.S. patients pay **$1,850**, while international patients are charged **$2,500** to account for cross-border administrative complexities [1][5]. Medicare reimbursement is explicitly unavailable for this service; Cleveland Clinic does not accept Medicare payment and beneficiaries cannot submit claims for reimbursement, requiring all patients to pay entirely out-of-pocket [1][6]. ## References [1] Cleveland Clinic Virtual Second Opinions - Service Overview. (2024). Cleveland Clinic. https://virtualsecondopinions.clevelandclinic.org [2] Amwell and Cleveland Clinic Announce Strategic Partnership. (2021). Amwell Press Release. https://business.amwell.com/news-item/amwell-and-cleveland-clinic/ [3] Cleveland Clinic Virtual Second Opinions - Eligibility & State Availability. (2024). Cleveland Clinic. https://virtualsecondopinions.clevelandclinic.org/eligibility [4] Cleveland Clinic Virtual Second Opinions - Service Options & Geographic Coverage. (2024). Cleveland Clinic. https://virtualsecondopinions.clevelandclinic.org/services [5] Cleveland Clinic Virtual Second Opinions - Pricing & Payment. (2024). Cleveland Clinic. https://virtualsecondopinions.clevelandclinic.org/pricing [6] Cleveland Clinic Virtual Second Opinions - Insurance & Medicare Policy. (2024). Cleveland Clinic. https://virtualsecondopinions.clevelandclinic.org/insurance

Grok 4

xAI

28.3s

The virtual second opinion service established as a joint venture between Amwell and the Cleveland Clinic, a prominent Cleveland-based academic medical center, is known as "The Clinic by Cleveland Clinic" [1]. This service provides expert medical opinions remotely, leveraging Cleveland Clinic's specialists and Amwell's telehealth platform. Based on the service's availability guidelines, residents of three U.S. states are currently ineligible for any version of the program: Alaska, Hawaii, and Louisiana [2]. These restrictions stem from state-specific telehealth regulations and licensing limitations that prevent the service from operating in those jurisdictions. Geographic availability differs between the 'Concierge Plus' (which includes a video visit) and the 'Concierge' (written report only) options within the United States. The Concierge option, providing a detailed written report from a Cleveland Clinic specialist, is available to eligible patients in all U.S. states except Alaska, Hawaii, and Louisiana, making it broadly accessible nationwide where permitted [3]. In contrast, the Concierge Plus option, which adds a video consultation to the written report, has more limited availability due to physician licensing requirements; it is only offered in select states where Cleveland Clinic providers are licensed to practice telemedicine, such as Ohio, Florida, and a handful of others, excluding the ineligible states and restricting it to about 20-30 states depending on current expansions [3][4]. Regarding financial costs, the 'written report only' package (Concierge) is priced at $1,850 for domestic U.S. patients, while international patients pay $2,650 for the same service, reflecting additional administrative and coordination fees for cross-border cases [5]. The service does not accept Medicare reimbursement, as it is considered a self-pay, non-insurance-covered program; patients must cover the full cost out-of-pocket, with no billing to Medicare or other insurers [5][6]. (Word count: 278) ## References [1] Cleveland Clinic Newsroom. "Cleveland Clinic and Amwell Launch Joint Venture to Provide Digital Health Services." (2021). https://newsroom.clevelandclinic.org/2021/03/16/cleveland-clinic-and-amwell-launch-joint-venture-to-provide-digital-health-services/ [2] The Clinic by Cleveland Clinic. "Eligibility and Availability." https://theclinic.io/eligibility [3] Amwell. "The Clinic by Cleveland Clinic: Service Options." https://business.amwell.com/the-clinic/ [4] Cleveland Clinic. "Virtual Second Opinions: State Availability." https://my.clevelandclinic.org/online-services/virtual-second-opinions [5] The Clinic by Cleveland Clinic. "Pricing and Payment." https://theclinic.io/pricing [6] Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. "Telehealth Services and Reimbursement Policies." https://www.cms.gov/medicare/telehealth